Tuesday, August 19, 2008

Judge PPO Allows More Time...

Back on August 14, 2008... Judge Peter Paul Olszewski filed an order that briefs be filed on the motion to suppress. Today... PPO once again allows defendant Joseph Kerekes' attorneys an enlargement of time to file:

08/14/2008 Order of Court filed. Briefs to be filed on Motion to Suppress - Olszewski, Peter Paul Jr.

08/19/2008 Motion for Enlargement of Time to File Def's Brief In Support of Motion to Suppress & Order-Granted - Olszewski, Peter Paul Jr.

Guess there's still a few motions of suppression that PPO hasn't decided upon yet... here's hoping he can at least rule on a few of the other previously filed motions this week, including the one's filed by Harlow Cuadra's attorneys. Though to quote PPO from the last hearing: “No sense in rushing it at this point”... so who knows.

In PPO's defense however... he was a former district attorney who has dealt with most/if not all of these attorneys previously both as a judge and/or as a foe, and I still honestly believe he has complete control over this case.

----
Update @ 08/21/2008: The Times Leader is saying that attorneys for homicide suspect Joseph Kerekes have asked a judge for more time to file court papers stating Kerekes’ stance on a motion to suppress evidence seized from his vehicle.

Kerekes, 34, and his partner, Harlow Cuadra, 27, both from Virginia Beach, Va., were stopped and arrested by Virginia Beach authorities while driving on Virginia Beach Boulevard, according to court records, shortly after investigators in Pennsylvania filed criminal homicide charges in the January 2007 slaying of Bryan Kocis, 44, in Dallas Township.

In court papers filed Tuesday, Kerekes’ attorneys, John Pike and Shelley Centini, asked for a two-week extension on filing their response because they have not yet received a police report concerning the arrest of Kerekes and the search of his vehicle in Virginia Beach.

“Counsel is unable to author any meaningful brief without possessing information relative to Mr. Kerekes’ arrest and search of his vehicle,” court papers say. “Such extension would not delay the hearing presently scheduled in the matter, nor would such extension prejudice the Commonwealth.”

Centini and Pike claim that “Virginia authorities possessed no warrant for (Kerekes’) arrest, nor did (Kerekes) commit any motor vehicle offense which would authorize a traffic stop,” according to their court filing.

After Kerekes and Cuadra were arrested, their vehicle was searched by Virginia authorities and certain items were seized, Centini and Pike said. One of the items taken from their vehicle, according to court records, was a knife.

Luzerne County assistant district attorneys Michael Melnick, Shannon Crake and Allyson Kacmarski are seeking the death penalty for Kerekes and Cuadra if they are convicted. Prosecutors claim in court records that Kerekes and Cuadra killed Kocis, whom they considered their main rival in the gay pornographic film industry.

A hearing on the issue is still scheduled for Sept. 22.

Sunday, August 17, 2008

PPO Expected to Rule on Several Motions this Week...

Judge Peter Paul Olszewski

Judge Peter Paul Olszewski is expected to file some rulings this week on a myriad of motions that have been filed by the defense... most notably are... if Harlow Cuadra and Joseph Kerekes can have separate trials, if the trial(s) is held in Luzerne County or a jury from another county is brought in, and if prosecutors can use recorded conversations from Black's Beach and the Crab Catcher Restaurant.

Other motions PPO could rule on include: Cuadra's Writ of Habeas Corpus, and just about anything else Harlow's attorneys filed in his lengthy omnibus pre-trial motion.

I personally think Cuadra and Kerekes will lose almost every motion, if not all. The only two I can think of that I'd consider 'iffy' are the severance motion, and Kerekes' motion to suppress statements made after arrest... and even with those two question marks... I'm leaning towards PPO saying no.

What do you think the rulings will be?

Update @ 08/22/2008: Sources are now telling me that he will likely announce his rulings next Tuesday or Wednesday.

Saturday, August 16, 2008

Deputy DA Moving up to AG’s Office

According to the Times Leader... one of the DA's assigned to Harlow Cuadra and Joseph Kerekes' murder trial will be leaving office...

Tim Doherty will prosecute drug cases in eight-county area for attorney general.

Doherty, 52, who spent nine years as a Luzerne County assistant district attorney, has accepted the position as deputy state attorney general assigned to the state Office of Attorney General’s Bureau of Narcotics Investigation and Drug Control.

The former Scranton police officer will prosecute narcotics offenses that occur in eight Northeastern Pennsylvania counties.

“I saw this as an opportunity to be a good stepping stone, moving up the ladder in the criminal justice system,” Doherty said Friday during a gathering of co-workers. “This will allow me to focus on one area of the law, narcotics.”

Doherty was hired by then-District Attorney Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. in February 1999. He stayed during District Attorney David Lupas’ eight-year tenure, moving through the ranks to become a special assistant United States attorney for the Middle District of Pennsylvania.

Soon after Jacqueline Musto Carroll became district attorney in January, she appointed Doherty as the office’s deputy district attorney, giving him more authority over thousands of cases.

Musto Carroll said she will miss Doherty’s energetic work ethic.

“An opportunity like this doesn’t come around often,” Musto Carroll said. “I’m very proud one of our own has been chosen.”

She described Doherty as a tireless “prosecutor’s prosecutor,” who will be missed in the office.

Although he will miss the “daily grind” of handling multiple cases on a variety of crimes, Doherty said he is looking forward to focusing on prosecuting drug dealers.

“With the district attorney’s office, you’re handling everything, and you really don’t have the time that you really want to put in on a case,” Doherty said.

One crime Doherty took special interest in was arson.

Doherty explained he saw an opportunity early in his career to gather experience when he noticed arson cases were being assigned among different assistant district attorneys. He said arson cases are difficult to prosecute because evidence is destroyed and there are usually no eye witnesses.

It wasn’t unusual to see Doherty, wearing a suit and dress shoes, inside a smoldering building holding a flashlight, a note pad and talking to firefighters and fire inspectors.

Doherty said he became a prosecutor because he wanted more control over how cases are settled.

“As a police officer, you can only do so much as cases progress through the system,” Doherty said.

Friday, August 15, 2008

Kocis Case May See Infirmity Defense

The Times Leader reports that attorneys for homicide suspects Harlow Cuadra and Joseph Kerekes are expected to mount a mental-infirmity defense if they are convicted in the January 2007 slaying of gay pornographic film producer Bryan Kocis.

Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty for the two Virginia Beach, Va., men because Kocis, 44, was killed during the commission of a felony -- robbery, one of 18 aggravating factors required for capital punishment, according to the state’s crimes code.

A mental-infirmity defense during the death penalty phase is one of several mitigating circumstances that counters the aggravating factors.

Attorneys for the two men, as required by law, advised prosecutors that they intend to present evidence of mental infirmity.

In turn, prosecutors were permitted by Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. on Thursday to have Cuadra, 27, and Kerekes, 34, submit to an independent psychiatric evaluation.

Prosecutors were instructed to submit their mental evaluations that are to be sealed by Dec. 1.

If a jury convicts the two men, the trial moves to the death penalty phase where prosecutors can present their mental evaluation findings.

Their trial is scheduled to begin with jury selection on Jan. 5.

Prosecutors claim in court records that Cuadra and Kerekes killed Kocis, whom they considered their main rival in the gay movie industry.

Kocis’ body was found inside his Dallas Township home on Jan. 24, 2007, by firefighters who responded to a fire at his Midland Drive residence.

Olszewski is expected to file his rulings next week that determines if Cuadra and Kerekes will have separate trials, if the trials are held in Luzerne County or a jury from another county is brought in, and if prosecutors can use recorded conversations that allegedly implicates the two men in Kocis’ killing.
----
Note from PC: Additional information about an infirmity defense can be found in 234 Pa. Code Rule 568 and 569.

Thursday, August 14, 2008

Attorneys: Kerekes’ Rights Violated

The Times Leader is reporting that attorneys for homicide suspect Joseph Kerekes believe his arrest in May 2007 violated his civil rights.

In court records filed on Wednesday by attorneys Shelley Centini and John Pike, they claim authorities in Virginia didn’t have an arrest warrant when Kerekes was taken into custody on May 15, 2007.

Kerekes, 34, and his partner, Harlow Cuadra, 27, both from Virginia Beach, were stopped and arrested by Virginia Beach authorities while driving on Virginia Beach Boulevard.

They were arrested, according to court records, shortly after investigators in Pennsylvania filed criminal homicide charges with District Judge James E. Tupper in Trucksville for the January 2007 slaying of Bryan Kocis, 44, in Dallas Township.

Centini and Pike claim that, “Virginia authorities possessed no warrant for (Kerekes’) arrest, nor did (Kerekes) commit any motor vehicle offense which would authorize a traffic stop,” according to their court filing.

After Kerekes and Cuadra were arrested, their vehicle was searched by Virginia authorities and certain items were seized, Centini and Pike said. One of the items taken from their vehicle, according to court records, was a knife. Centini and Pike are seeking to prohibit prosecutors from using evidence taken from their vehicle.

Luzerne County Assistant District Attorneys Michael Melnick, Shannon Crake and Allyson Kacmarski are seeking the death penalty for Kerekes and Cuadra. Prosecutors claim in court records that Kerekes and Cuadra killed Kocis, whom they considered their main rival in the gay pornography movie industry.

Responding to a request by Cuadra’s and Kerekes’ attorneys on Tuesday, Court of Common Pleas Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. delayed the September trial until January 2009. Their attorneys requested that a third attorney be appointed to each defense team that would replace attorneys Mark Bufalino and Paul Galante, who withdrew from the case in July citing a conflict of interest.

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

The Defense Delay Game?

With more twists and turns than San Fransico's famed Lombard Street... Harlow Cuadra and Joseph Kerekes' defense teams have created more excuses for delays than the airlines do... and while not every one of these incidents can be solely blamed on the defense (though they were always the cause of it), I've gone ahead and compiled a list of actions, or mis-actions that have caused this trial to be delayed several times... with the most recent being yesterday:

November 23, 2007: 'Blum said a conflict existed with public defenders representing both men because the men, at trial, could accuse the other as the principal killer. Also, Blum and attorney Al Flora Jr., the county’s first assistant public defender, had represented Kocis in the past and might be witnesses at the homicide trial'.

December 4, 2007: 'Cuadra's attorneys want the trial delayed. They said they need more time to prepare'.

January 4, 2008: 'Homicide suspect Harlow Cuadra will get new attorneys and a new trial date'.

January 28, 2008 'Attorney Demetrius Fannick on Monday filed court papers indicating he will be representing Cuadra in his homicide case'.

March 19, 2008: 'Attorney Demetrius Fannick’s decision not to testify about his meetings with homicide suspect Joseph Kerekes led to the attorney being ousted from representing Cuadra.'

April 17, 2008: 'Harlow Cuadra has appealed a judge's ruling that forbid attorney Demetrius Fannick from representing him.'

July 9, 2008: 'Bufalino, one of three attorneys representing Kerekes, told the judge he and Paul Galante are associates in the same firm. Galante is one of three attorneys representing Cuadra. And, attorney John Pike, co-representing Kerekes, announced he had represented Robert Rodden, a prosecution witness'.

July 10, 2008: 'The two defense attorneys dismissed Wednesday from the capital murder case against Harlow Cuadra and Joseph Kerekes were aware of their potential conflict of interest since May and should have moved to remove themselves sooner, Luzerne County Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. said'.

August 12, 2008: 'Kerekes' attorney, Shelley Centini, asked to continue the trial because she had not received Bufalino's file on the case. In addition, Cuadra's attorney, Michael Senape, said he has not yet been certified in defending capital murder trials.'

... all of which leads me to the poll question: "Do You Think Defense Attorneys are Deliberatley Delaying the Trial?"... I say yes... what are your thoughts?

New Trial Date: January 5, 2009

According the Citizens' Voice... the start of the trial for accused killers Harlow Cuadra and Joseph Kerekes will be postponed until January, Luzerne County Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. said Tuesday, after attorneys for both defendants argued their preparation had been hampered by the dismissal of two colleagues last month.

Olszewski, who had reiterated his commitment to the scheduled Sept. 2 start date at nearly every pre-trial hearing since he set the court calendar in April, said the trial will now begin Jan. 5.

“I obviously have no control over it at this point,” Olszewski said, glaring at the defense attorneys seated on the left side of his courtroom. “I’m telling everybody right now, there will be no additional continuances.”

Shelley Centini, an attorney for Kerekes, asked for the postponement after meeting with Olszewski and the other attorneys on the case for more than an hour in the judge’s chambers.

Centini said the removal last month of Mark Bufalino from Kerekes’ defense team left the remaining attorneys unprepared. Centini said she had not received important case files from Bufalino and could not be sure her files contained all of the material he had previously collected.

“Without the documents from Mr. Bufalino, it makes it difficult if not impossible to prepare for trial,” Centini said.

Olszewski said Bufalino told him by telephone Tuesday that Kerekes’ attorneys never requested the file.

Cuadra, 27, and Kerekes, 34, both of Virginia Beach, Va., are accused of killing Bryan Kocis, a rival producer of gay pornographic films and later setting fire to his Midland Drive home.

They face the death penalty.

Olszewski ruled last month that Bufalino and Paul Galante, an attorney for Cuadra, could no longer serve on the case because the two attorneys work for the same law firm — the Wilkes-Barre office of Elliott Greenleaf.

Bufalino, Shelley Centini and John Pike were appointed last October to represent Kerekes. Galante, Stephen Menn and Michael Senape were assigned in January to represent Cuadra.

They are all members of the county’s conflict counsel pool, a separate group of publicly funded attorneys assigned to cases when a defendant is unable to retain a private attorney and a public defender cannot be used because of a conflict of interest.

Of the remaining attorneys on the case, only Pike and Menn are certified by the state Supreme Court to handle death penalty cases. Under state law, each defense team must have at least one attorney who is death penalty certified. Senape told Olszewski he is working toward receiving death penalty certification.

Olszewski asked President Judge Mark A. Ciavarella last month to appoint attorneys to fill the vacancies created by the removal of Bufalino and Galante.

Possible replacements include the five attorneys left in the conflict counsel pool: Brian Corcoran, Joseph Cosgrove, Samuel Falcone Jr., Matthew Kelly and Gerald Wassil.

Ciavarella has yet to act, Olszewski said.

Attorneys in the case are under a court-imposed gag order and are not permitted to publicly comment on any developments.

Centini’s request came at what had been scheduled as a pre-trial conference and Olszewski was expected to rule on a number of defense motions, including requests to suppress evidence and hold separate trials for Cuadra and Kerekes.

Olszewski said he has completed nearly all of his rulings on the motions and would issue a set of opinions next week. Olszewski said he would reschedule the pre-trial conference for mid-November.

“No sense in rushing it at this point,” Olszewski said.
----

Meanwhile, the Times Leader says... cancel the September murder trial for double homicide suspects Harlow Cuadra and Joseph Kerekes.

Attorneys for the two Virginia men on Tuesday requested to delay the trial until a third attorney for each man is appointed by the court.

Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. granted the request, rescheduling the trial to begin Jan. 5 with jury selection. The trial had been scheduled to start Sept. 2.

The two are accused in the January 2007 slaying of Dallas Township gay film producer Bryan Kocis, 44, at Kocis’ Midland Drive home.

Luzerne County Assistant District Attorneys Michael Melnick, Shannon Crake and Allyson Kacmarski are seeking the death penalty for Cuadra, 27, and Kerekes, 34, both of Virginia Beach.

Kerekes’ attorneys, Shelley Centini and John Pike, and Cuadra’s attorneys, Michael Senape and Stephen Menn, requested to delay the trial until a third attorney is appointed to assist them in defending their clients.

The yet-to-be appointed attorneys will replace attorney Mark Bufalino, who co-represented Kerekes, and attorney Paul Galante, who co-represented Cuadra.

Bufalino and Galante withdrew from the case on July 10 citing a conflict of interest because they work in the same private law firm. After Bufalino and Galante were permitted to withdraw last month, Olszewski said he would appoint attorneys to replace them.

At Tuesday’s pre-trial hearing, Olszewski said attempts are still being made to find attorneys who are qualified in defending death penalty cases.

Centini said in her request to delay the trial that she hadn’t received Bufalino’s file. Without Bufalino’s file, Centini said, “It would make it entirely difficult but not impossible” to defend Cuadra.

In a telephone conversation on Tuesday, Olszewski said Bufalino related that Cuadra’s attorneys have all necessary court records.

Olszewski said he expects to file his rulings next week on requests by attorneys for Cuadra and Kerekes for separate trials and to prohibit prosecutors from using conversations that were recorded in San Diego, Calif., in April 2007.

Investigators recorded conversations between Cuadra and Kerekes and Grant Roy, a pornographic film producer, and actor Sean Lockhart. During the conversations, Cuadra and Kerekes allegedly admitted to being involved in the killing, according to court records.

Prosecutors claim in court records that Cuadra and Kerekes killed Kocis because they wanted to film movies with Lockhart, who was a contract model for Kocis’ company Cobra Video.

Tuesday, August 12, 2008

Harlow and Joe's Trial Delayed

The Citizens' Voice is reporting that the capital murder trial of accused killers Harlow Cuadra and Joseph Kerekes has been delayed until Jan. 5, 2009.

Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. made the scheduling change Tuesday, from an original start date of Sept. 2, after attorneys for both defendants requested a continuance.

Shelley Centini, an attorney for Kerekes, said the dismissal last month of Mark Bufalino, an attorney for Kerekes, and Paul Galante, an attorney for Cuadra, left both defense teams unprepared for trial.

Cuadra, 27, and Kerekes, 34, both of Virginia Beach, Va., are accused of killing Bryan Kocis, a rival producer of gay pornographic films and later setting fire to his Midland Drive home.
----

Update @ 2:50 PM: The Times Leader is also reporting that the capital murder trial for Harlow Cuadra and Joseph Kerekes has been postponed until January 2009.

Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. postponed the trial after attorneys for the two Virginia Beach, Va., men argued attorneys Mark Bufalino and Paul Galante have not been replaced.

Bufalino represented Kerekes, and Galante represented Cuadra. The two attorneys withdrew from the case in July due to a conflict that they both work in the same private law firm.

Kerekes' attorney, Shelley Centini, asked to continue the trial because she had not received Bufalino's file on the case.

In addition, Cuadra's attorney, Michael Senape, said he has not yet been certified in defending capital murder trials.

Olszewski postponed the trial that was initially scheduled to begin on Sept. 2 to Jan. 5.

Cuadra, 27, and Kerekes, 34, are charged in the slaying of Bryan Kocis, 44, at Kocis' Dallas Township home in January 2007. Prosecutors claim in court records that they killed Kocis, whom they considered their rival in the gay pornographic movie industry.
----

Update @ 3:49 PM: Harlow Cuadra signs documents waiving his right to a speedy trial... Joseph Kerekes already did this several months ago.