Showing posts sorted by date for query Ciavarella. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query Ciavarella. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Monday, February 16, 2009

Jury Selection for Cuadra Trial Set to Begin Tuesday

The Citizens' Voice reports: The last time Harlow Cuadra shuffled into the Luzerne County Courthouse, for a hearing on Dec. 16, the clouds of judicial corruption preoccupying the court system were still on the periphery.

The county’s president judge at the time, Mark A. Ciavarella Jr., and former president judge, Michael T. Conahan, were still on the bench — six weeks from being charged with wire fraud and conspiracy to commit tax fraud in a scheme to send juveniles to a private prison for profit.

The county’s court administrator, William T. Sharkey Sr., was still on an extended medical leave of absence. He is scheduled to plead guilty Tuesday to a charge of embezzlement for allegedly diverting $70,000 in gambling proceeds for his own personal use.

In the wake of the scandals, the judge presiding over Cuadra’s case, Peter Paul Olszewski Jr., has emerged as a vocal proponent of reform — advocating for increased transparency in the court’s hiring practices and a cost-effective system for paying conflict attorneys.

Olszewski, 49, provided the only challenge to Judge Chester B. Muroski in the Jan. 26 vote for president judge that followed Ciavarella’s resignation from the position and, if successful in his bid for retention in November, could be a leading contender to replace Muroski, 69, who must retire at the end of the year.

Olszewski will be on the bench Tuesday when jury selection is scheduled to begin in Cuadra’s trial for the killing of Bryan Kocis, a rival producer of gay pornographic films, in Dallas Township in January 2007.

Cuadra’s co-defendant, Joseph Kerekes, 34, pleaded guilty Dec. 8 to second-degree murder and other charges and was sentenced to life in prison without parole, the mandatory term for a second-degree murder conviction.

Cuadra refused a plea agreement and faces the death penalty. He has been charged with an open count of homicide. He had been scheduled to stand trial Jan. 5, but Olszewski approved a six-week delay to allow two private attorneys hired by Cuadra, Joseph D’Andrea of Dunmore and Paul J. Walker of Scranton, “a reasonable amount of time to prepare” for the case.

Cuadra and Kerekes were arrested in Virginia Beach in May 2007 and were originally scheduled to stand trial together in March. Days before the start of the trial, Olszewski disqualified attorney Demetrius Fannick from representing Cuadra and delayed the trial until Sept. 2.

Olszewski delayed the start of the trial again in August after ruling Mark Bufalino, an attorney for Kerekes, and Paul Galante, an attorney for Cuadra, could no longer serve on the case because the two attorneys work for the same law firm — the Wilkes-Barre office of Elliott Greenleaf.

Kerekes, 34, of Virginia Beach, Va., entered into a tentative plea agreement with prosecutors the day before his guilty plea, after more than nine hours of negotiations at the state police barracks at Wyoming.

Kerekes said he will not testify against Cuadra.

During the negotiations at the state police barracks, Kerekes gave a statement “to develop a factual basis for the plea,” Assistant District Attorney Michael Melnick said.

Kerekes told prosecutors he and Cuadra viewed Kocis, a rival producer of gay pornographer, as an “impediment to the expansion of their pornography business,” Melnick said.

“They decided to eliminate and kill Bryan Kocis,” Melnick said.

Melnick will lead the same prosecution team, including Assistant District Attorneys Shannon Crake and Allyson Kacmarski, at Cuadra’s trial.

According to Kerekes, Cuadra ordered an online background check of Kocis days before the murder, sent e-mail messages and photographs to Kocis, placed telephone calls to him on a cell phone purchased and used only to call Kocis, and rented a vehicle that was seen by witnesses in Kocis’ driveway around the time of the killing.

Cuadra wrote to Kocis posing as an inexperienced pornographic film actor named “Danny Moilin” and used the character as a ruse to gain a private meeting with Kocis, 46, who led a nearly reclusive life in Dallas Township, Kerekes said.

Cuadra went alone to Kocis’ home on Midland Drive while Kerekes stayed at the Fox Ridge Inn in Plains Township, Kerekes said. Cuadra allegedly slashed Kocis’ neck, nearly decapitating him, and stabbed his torso nearly 30 times and later set fire to his Midland Drive home.

Cuadra returned to the motel in the rented vehicle and the two men fled to Virginia, Kerekes said.

Investigators found links between Cuadra, Kerekes and the killing in a February search of the Virginia Beach, Va., home where the alleged killers lived, including two Sony digital video cameras that had been taken from Kocis’ home.

Cuadra and Kerekes shared vivid details about the killing in conversations recorded by investigators in San Diego in April 2007.

Cuadra and Kerekes met with Grant Roy, a former suspect turned informant, and Sean Lockhart, Roy’s lover and business partner.

Lockhart had acted in gay pornographic films produced by Kocis’ company, Cobra Video. He and Roy had been engaged in a lawsuit over the use of his stage name, Brent Corrigan.

A settlement reached on Jan. 18, 2007, less than a week before the killing, allowed Lockhart to star in movies not involving Cobra Video, in exchange for a payment of 20 percent of the proceeds to Cobra.

Both men are expected to testify at Cuadra’s trial.

Roy asked Cuadra and Kerekes if Kocis felt any pain as he was being killed. After a few moments of silence, Cuadra leaned toward Lockhart and said quietly, “Don’t worry, he went quick.”

Cuadra offered more details the next day, as he walked with Kerekes, Roy and Lockhart along a nude beach in the La Jolla section of San Diego. Roy captured the conversation with a recording device hidden in a car key remote.

“Actually, seeing that (expletive) going down, actually it’s sick, but it made me feel better inside,” Cuadra said, referring to Kocis.

“It almost felt like I got revenge and I know that sounds (expletive) up.”
---

[PC Notes: Just in case you missed this when I posted it on 11/25/08, here's a copy of the Defendant's Proposed Voir Dire... also, the ages given for Kerekes and Kocis in this story are incorrect, Kerekes is 35 and Kocis was 44.]

Tuesday, January 27, 2009

President Judge PPO?

The Citizens' Voice reported this morning that "Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas judges will meet at noon Friday to vote for a successor for president judge, according to a news release from Judge Chester B. Muroski.

Muroski took over as acting president judge on Monday as former President Judge Mark A. Ciavarella Jr. stepped down from that post."


With all of the events that unfolded yesterday... it got me thinking about who the next president judge would be... could it be Judge Peter Paul Olszewski, Jr., and if he is selected, would it effect Harlow's trial date?

After speaking with a source familiar with the situation, I'm told that they (the source) already have him penciled in as the next president judge. The others (judges) are either on the verge of mandatory retirement, not as experienced, or already served as PJ. Plus, PPO's well respected and a hard worker.

My source goes on to say that if PPO is selected, it won't have any impact on Harlow Cuadra's trial at all. He'd assume some additional administrative duties, but nothing that would prevent him from altering a trial already scheduled for next month.

Guess we'll see on Friday. :)

Update 01/29/2009: The Times Leader is reporting that for the first time in the history of Luzerne County court, the election of the new president judge will be open to the public, acting president Judge Chester Muroski announced today.

Mursoki said the vote, scheduled for Friday at noon, must be taken by secret ballot as required by law. The results of the vote will immediately be read in open court, however. The new president judge will then be immediately sworn in.

The judges will meet in courtroom number four at the Luzerne County Courthouse on North River St., Wilkes-Barre.

Monday, January 26, 2009

And in Other News...

The Citizens' Voice reports that Luzerne County judges Mark A. Ciavarella and Michael Conahan were charged today with two counts of conspiracy to impede the Internal Revenue Service in collecting federal income taxes and a scheme to defraud the citizens of Luzerne County and Pennsylvania of the right to their honest services.

Ciavarella and Conahan were charged with concealing the receipt of $2.6 million between January 2003 and April 2007. They have filed a plea agreement, signed by both judges, and pleaded guilty to honest service fraud and income tax conspiracy.

The judges stipulated they will resign their judgeship and be disbarred. They will serve 87 months in federal prison and make restitution as stipulated by the court.

Update: Press Release from U.S. Attorney General on Luzerne judges, and Information on Charges... and Ciavarella's Resignation Letter.

Update 2: Ciavarella's plea agreement ... Conahan's plea agreement.

Update 3: According to the Citizen's Voice: The information filed today alleges the judges received payments from two persons, identified as Individual # 1 and Individual # 2. They are not named, but the information says Individual # 1 was a Luzerne County attorney who was an owner of the Pennsylvania Child Care juvenile detention center that is at the core of the government’s case. Butler Township attorney Robert J. Powell was until June one of two co-owners of Pennsylvania Child Care. The other owner, Gregory Zappala, who is now sole owner of the firm, is a Pittsburgh-area investment banker.

The information says Individual #2 was the contractor that built Pennsylvania Child Care’s local facilty and another in Butler County. The contractor for both projects was Mericle Construction Inc., headed by local developer Robert Mericle.

Neither Powell nor Mericle responded immediately to requests for comment.

Update 4: Ciavarella releases a statement.

Update 5: State Supreme Court removes Conahan, Ciavarella from the bench.

Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Two County Judges Announce Retention Bids

While this doesn't really have anything to do with the upcoming trial itself (other than a brief mention of Harlow and Joe), I thought it was an interesting article from today's Citizens' Voice, as it gives a little background information on Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr.:

Luzerne County judges Thomas F. Burke Jr. and Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. have filed declarations to be retention candidates on the November election ballot, Pennsylvania Department of State spokeswoman Leslie Amoros confirmed Monday.

Monday was the deadline for judges to file declarations that allow voters to decide whether to approve or deny another 10-year term on the bench.

County Commissioner Stephen A. Urban on Monday repeated his stance that voters should reject every county judge currently on the bench when up for retention.

Urban is the only Republican serving as a county commissioner or as a county row officer. Burke is the only Republican among the nine current judges on the county bench.

“Vote them all out,” Urban said. “They’re all part of the system.”

President Judge Mark A. Ciavarella Jr. and the county judges have initiated litigation over court funding because county commissioners want to reduce judicial branch salaries by $1.9 million. Attorneys agreed to a temporary truce that the 2009 budget will be in effect starting Jan. 1 for non-court departments, while the judiciary would be funded at 2008 amounts until the litigation is resolved.

Olszewski and Burke declined to respond directly to the litigation or Urban’s comments on voting against incumbent judges.

“Obviously, I play no role in the budget process,” Olszewski said. “I’m sure when November comes, the voters of this county will review my record and review everything I’ve done on the bench over the last 10 years, and they will vote to retain me by a large margin … I’m confident that I’ll do well.”

Burke, 62, was appointed by former Gov. Tom Ridge in May 1998 to fill the Court of Common Pleas seat vacated by Judge Correale Stevens’ election to the state Superior Court.

Burke and Olszewski won election to their current 10-year terms in November 1999, running virtually unopposed after defeating attorney Virginia Murtha Cowley and Magisterial District Judge Fred Pierantoni for the Republican and Democratic party nominations in the May primary.

Olszewski, 49, served as Luzerne County district attorney for eight years prior to his election to the Court of Common Pleas. He graduated from Penn State and earned his law degree from the Dickinson School of Law.

His father, Peter Paul Olszewski Sr., served on the state Superior Court from 1983 to 2005 and on the Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas from 1967 to 1983.

As a judge, Olszewski Jr. has presided over several prominent cases, including the first capital murder trial of Hugo Selenski and the capital murder case against Joseph Kerekes and Harlow Cuadra.

Selenski was acquitted in March 2006 on two murder charges, but convicted on two counts of abusing a corpse. Olszewski recused himself in August 2006 from hearing Selenski’s pending trial on two other killings.

Kerekes pleaded guilty last month to second-degree murder and other charges in the death of Bryan Kocis in Dallas Township in January 2007. Cuadra is scheduled to stand trial for the same killing Feb. 17.

Last March, Olszewski gained national notoriety when he ordered three immigrants from the Dominican Republic to learn English or face a prison sentence. The men were charged with armed assault and robbery after being accused of jumping two men, pulling a gun on them, and hitting one of them with a dog bone in Hazleton.

If the men learned English and passed a test a year later, they would be allowed to remain free, but if they failed, they would have to go back to jail to serve the rest of the sentence, Olszewski said.

“As a general proposition, I believe experience is a very great advantage for a jurist,” Burke said. “I do, in fact, believe in the retention system.”

Burke graduated with honors from Lehigh University, received his law degree from Villanova University and practiced as an attorney for 25 years before ascending to the bench. He served in the U.S. Army and fought in the Vietnam War, and was awarded a Bronze Star for meritorious service.

As a judge, Burke has handled thousands of civil and criminal matters and is expected to preside over the planned retrial of James Lincoln Strong, the Georgia man accused of killing a man off Interstate 81 in Dorrance Township in 1983.

The court-county litigation is currently in a discovery phase, in which depositions will take place, county solicitor Vito DeLuca said. A hearing on the budget dispute will take place after discovery, which will last at least 30 days, DeLuca said.

Saturday, November 15, 2008

Harlow's Attorney to Resign From Conflict Counsel Pool

The Citizen's Voice is reporting that attorney Stephen Menn, a member of the court-appointed teams defending accused killers Hugo Selenski and Harlow Cuadra, gave notice Thursday that he will resign from the Luzerne County conflict counsel pool at the end of the year.

Menn, a member of the conflict pool since 1998, said last week he had grown frustrated with the system and the intense workload, which included simultaneously handling five homicide cases.

Menn, who also maintains a private practice in West Pittston and is the solicitor for Wyoming Borough, declined to comment when reached by telephone Friday and did not return telephone messages left at his office and his home later in the day.

Luzerne County District Attorney Jackie Musto Carroll said she had heard about Menn’s discontent with the system and murmurs that he was considering resigning.

“I’m sorry to hear that he did,” Musto Carroll said Friday.

Paul McGarry, the director of court administrative services, said Friday he was unaware of Menn’s resignation but that “it could be in the system somewhere” and had not yet reached his office.

President Judge Mark A. Ciavarella Jr. runs the conflict counsel system and will ultimately be responsible for accepting Menn’s resignation and hiring a replacement, McGarry said. Ciavarella did not return telephone messages Friday. The conflict counsel pool is a group of publicly funded attorneys assigned to cases when a defendant is unable to retain a private attorney and a public defender cannot be used because of a conflict of interest with another defendant or a witness.

Each of the 11 members of the pool earn an annual salary of $26,946.86 and full health benefits, according to county payroll records.

Menn, Pike, Mark Bufalino and Paul Galante are the only members of the conflict pool certified to handle death penalty cases like Selenski’s and Cuadra’s. The lead counsel on all death penalty cases must be certified under guidelines established by the state Supreme Court in 2003, Pike said.

Wednesday, November 12, 2008

Where's the Third Attorney?

With less than 2 months to go before the trial is scheduled to start, Harlow Cuadra and Joseph Kerekes still don't have their replacement attorney(s).

If you'll recall, Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. agreed to dismiss Mark Bufalino, who represented Joseph Kerekes, and Galante, who represented Harlow Cuadra, because the two attorneys requested to be withdrawn from the case in July, due to a conflict that they both work in the same private law firm.

Possible replacements include the five attorneys left in the conflict counsel pool: Brian Corcoran, Joseph Cosgrove, Samuel Falcone Jr., Matthew Kelly and Gerald Wassil.

Olszewski asked President Judge Mark A. Ciavarella in July to appoint attorneys to fill the vacancies created by the removal of Bufalino and Galante, and as of now... no attorneys have been assigned.

Time certainly doesn't seem to be of the essence... I sure hope this doesn't wind up causing another trial delay.

Sunday, September 7, 2008

An Open Response to Blogger Albert

"What cause was Demetrius Fannick fired for? The answer is no cause. Just suspicion. Nothing derogatory was proven, only accusations were made and for PPO that was good enough. He himself fired the only attorney Harlow himself had hired."

While as sensational as this may sound, it's simply not correct. Demetrius Fannick was removed from defending Harlow Cuadra due to his previous involvement with Joseph Kerekes. Here's the entire saga to that story (whether you or I agree, or disagree... PA law does trump our opinion):

Demetrius Fannick

"Observe who appointed and who subsequently fired the other attorney's."

In almost all of the cases... it was Judge Ciavarella who appointed counsel, but I'm not sure as to who 'fired' any attorneys (other than perhaphs themselves), since they were all removed due to conflict of interest.

"Whatever reason the State had for firing them would have been adequate reason for not hiring them in the first place. Still that hiring was done by the Stae of Pennsylvania through judical functionary."

To be fair, on every occasion, it was revealed that the conflict existed after-the-fact, usually by the defense attorneys themselves:

Joseph Kerekes Gets New Attorneys
DA: Get Cuadra Outside Counsel
A Potential Conflict Short-Circuts Hearing

"Now PPO wants to claim it is out of his hands? I fully expect this will figure significantly in the appeal process. As I have said so many times, 'Anywhere but Luzerne County.'"

It may very well be out of PPO's hands... and I'm sure it'll be used in the appeal process (assuming Harlow and Joe are found guilty). I mentioned months ago how long it takes for a capital murder trial to go from arraignment to trial... guess they should be happy they're not in N.Y., where it can take as long as 26 months.

"My question as to when and why another Judge was appointed to take over the responsibility of providing adequate representation is absolutely critical to this case. An assumption on yours or anyone's part is pointless, however well informed or intentioned."

Perhaps because that's the laws of PA. I guess my assumption would be no better than yours.

"This was a clearly investigated case. It is a case for the State to lose only by choice. Choices similar to the ones made in the much earlier Kocis case years ago. The investigators did their jobs in spades. The judiciary and the State of Pennsylvania will lose this of their own decision making."

Sounds like an assumption to me. :)

"Who put this other Judge in charge of this small portion of a capital case and under what authority?"

Judge Mark A. Ciavarella Jr. is the president judge, and apparently he's the 'decider'.

Note: I completely respect Albert's concern... so let's all have a friendly debate on the issue(s).

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

New Trial Date: January 5, 2009

According the Citizens' Voice... the start of the trial for accused killers Harlow Cuadra and Joseph Kerekes will be postponed until January, Luzerne County Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. said Tuesday, after attorneys for both defendants argued their preparation had been hampered by the dismissal of two colleagues last month.

Olszewski, who had reiterated his commitment to the scheduled Sept. 2 start date at nearly every pre-trial hearing since he set the court calendar in April, said the trial will now begin Jan. 5.

“I obviously have no control over it at this point,” Olszewski said, glaring at the defense attorneys seated on the left side of his courtroom. “I’m telling everybody right now, there will be no additional continuances.”

Shelley Centini, an attorney for Kerekes, asked for the postponement after meeting with Olszewski and the other attorneys on the case for more than an hour in the judge’s chambers.

Centini said the removal last month of Mark Bufalino from Kerekes’ defense team left the remaining attorneys unprepared. Centini said she had not received important case files from Bufalino and could not be sure her files contained all of the material he had previously collected.

“Without the documents from Mr. Bufalino, it makes it difficult if not impossible to prepare for trial,” Centini said.

Olszewski said Bufalino told him by telephone Tuesday that Kerekes’ attorneys never requested the file.

Cuadra, 27, and Kerekes, 34, both of Virginia Beach, Va., are accused of killing Bryan Kocis, a rival producer of gay pornographic films and later setting fire to his Midland Drive home.

They face the death penalty.

Olszewski ruled last month that Bufalino and Paul Galante, an attorney for Cuadra, could no longer serve on the case because the two attorneys work for the same law firm — the Wilkes-Barre office of Elliott Greenleaf.

Bufalino, Shelley Centini and John Pike were appointed last October to represent Kerekes. Galante, Stephen Menn and Michael Senape were assigned in January to represent Cuadra.

They are all members of the county’s conflict counsel pool, a separate group of publicly funded attorneys assigned to cases when a defendant is unable to retain a private attorney and a public defender cannot be used because of a conflict of interest.

Of the remaining attorneys on the case, only Pike and Menn are certified by the state Supreme Court to handle death penalty cases. Under state law, each defense team must have at least one attorney who is death penalty certified. Senape told Olszewski he is working toward receiving death penalty certification.

Olszewski asked President Judge Mark A. Ciavarella last month to appoint attorneys to fill the vacancies created by the removal of Bufalino and Galante.

Possible replacements include the five attorneys left in the conflict counsel pool: Brian Corcoran, Joseph Cosgrove, Samuel Falcone Jr., Matthew Kelly and Gerald Wassil.

Ciavarella has yet to act, Olszewski said.

Attorneys in the case are under a court-imposed gag order and are not permitted to publicly comment on any developments.

Centini’s request came at what had been scheduled as a pre-trial conference and Olszewski was expected to rule on a number of defense motions, including requests to suppress evidence and hold separate trials for Cuadra and Kerekes.

Olszewski said he has completed nearly all of his rulings on the motions and would issue a set of opinions next week. Olszewski said he would reschedule the pre-trial conference for mid-November.

“No sense in rushing it at this point,” Olszewski said.
----

Meanwhile, the Times Leader says... cancel the September murder trial for double homicide suspects Harlow Cuadra and Joseph Kerekes.

Attorneys for the two Virginia men on Tuesday requested to delay the trial until a third attorney for each man is appointed by the court.

Luzerne County Court of Common Pleas Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. granted the request, rescheduling the trial to begin Jan. 5 with jury selection. The trial had been scheduled to start Sept. 2.

The two are accused in the January 2007 slaying of Dallas Township gay film producer Bryan Kocis, 44, at Kocis’ Midland Drive home.

Luzerne County Assistant District Attorneys Michael Melnick, Shannon Crake and Allyson Kacmarski are seeking the death penalty for Cuadra, 27, and Kerekes, 34, both of Virginia Beach.

Kerekes’ attorneys, Shelley Centini and John Pike, and Cuadra’s attorneys, Michael Senape and Stephen Menn, requested to delay the trial until a third attorney is appointed to assist them in defending their clients.

The yet-to-be appointed attorneys will replace attorney Mark Bufalino, who co-represented Kerekes, and attorney Paul Galante, who co-represented Cuadra.

Bufalino and Galante withdrew from the case on July 10 citing a conflict of interest because they work in the same private law firm. After Bufalino and Galante were permitted to withdraw last month, Olszewski said he would appoint attorneys to replace them.

At Tuesday’s pre-trial hearing, Olszewski said attempts are still being made to find attorneys who are qualified in defending death penalty cases.

Centini said in her request to delay the trial that she hadn’t received Bufalino’s file. Without Bufalino’s file, Centini said, “It would make it entirely difficult but not impossible” to defend Cuadra.

In a telephone conversation on Tuesday, Olszewski said Bufalino related that Cuadra’s attorneys have all necessary court records.

Olszewski said he expects to file his rulings next week on requests by attorneys for Cuadra and Kerekes for separate trials and to prohibit prosecutors from using conversations that were recorded in San Diego, Calif., in April 2007.

Investigators recorded conversations between Cuadra and Kerekes and Grant Roy, a pornographic film producer, and actor Sean Lockhart. During the conversations, Cuadra and Kerekes allegedly admitted to being involved in the killing, according to court records.

Prosecutors claim in court records that Cuadra and Kerekes killed Kocis because they wanted to film movies with Lockhart, who was a contract model for Kocis’ company Cobra Video.

Saturday, November 24, 2007

D.A.: Get Cuadra Outside Counsel

Harlow Cuadra

The Times Leader reports: Prosecutors say public defenders should not be representing homicide suspect Harlow Cuadra.

The Luzerne County prosecutors say a conflict of interest exists with public defenders representing Cuadra because two public defenders previously represented the victim in the case, and now those two public defenders might be called to testify at Cuadra’s homicide trial.

The prosecutors want a judge to postpone all matters in the homicide case until attorneys from outside the public defender’s office are appointed to represent him.

Public defenders had been representing Cuadra and Kerekes. But Kerekes was later appointed public attorneys from outside the public defender’s office.

That came after a public defender, attorney Jonathan Blum, made the request. Blum said a conflict existed with public defenders representing both men because the men, at trial, could accuse the other as the principal killer.

Also, Blum and attorney Al Flora Jr., the county’s first assistant public defender, had represented Kocis in the past and might be witnesses at the homicide trial.

But Court of Common Pleas Judge Mark Ciavarella only appointed outside counsel to Kerekes.

The latest request to have attorneys from outside the public defender’s office represent Cuadra came this week by assistant district attorneys Mike Melnick, Tim Doherty, Shannon Crake and William Dunn.

They, too, said outside attorneys should be appointed to Cuadra because Blum and Flora represented Kocis in the past and are now potential witnesses in the homicide case.

Flora was interviewed by police in the homicide investigation and gave them information that was “relevant and material,” the prosecutors said.

Prosecutors say they want to ensure Cuadra “receives a fair and impartial trial.”

Ciavarella previously appointed attorneys John Pike, Mark Bufalino and Shelley Centini to defend Kerekes.

They are attorneys on the county payroll and not associated with the public defender’s office, and are provided to indigent defendants who have a conflict of interest with the public defenders.

Wednesday, November 21, 2007

Harlow and Joe's Dockets Updated Today

Update 11/23/07 @ 12:27 PM: The Times Leader has picked up the story, and basically reiterates what was mentioned in the previous update, one bit of new information though is that "the prosecutors want a judge to postpone all matters in the homicide case until attorneys from outside the public defender’s office are appointed to represent him" [Cuadra].

Update 11/23/07: The motions filed by the DA this past Wednesday was for the following reason:


The DA says the public defenders should not represent Cuadra because of a conflict of interest. Attorneys Al Flora and Jonathan Blum previously represented Bryan Kocis and might be called to testify at the Cuadra/Kerekes trial. Flora and Blum are public defenders, creating a conflict of interest.

If you recall, the public defenders office previously presented this motion to Judge Mark A. Ciavarella, Jr. on 10/12/07.

---
Both Harlow Cuadra and Joseph Kerekes' dockets have been updated today:

1. 11/21/2007 Comm's Motion to Disquaify PD's Office to Represent Def-Harlow Cuadra filed by Luzerne County District Attorney's Office

2. 11/21/2007 Comm's Brief In Support of Motion to Disqualify PD from Representation of Def-Harlow Cuadra filed by Luzerne County District Attorney's Office

I'm trying to find out exactly why these motions were filed, as I'd prefer to not speculate. Not sure I'll get an answer until Friday, but here's to keeping my fingers crossed.

Saturday, October 13, 2007

Joseph Kerekes Gets New Attorneys

Joseph Kerekes

Update (4:07 AM): Citizens Voice also covers the story:

"Blum argued Cuadra or Kerekes might blame one another for slashing Kocis' throat and killing him before the fire. The accomplice defense creates an obvious conflict for the office, Blum said in a motion seeking new counsel.

Blum also contends another conflict arises from his and First Assistant Public Defender Al Flora's past representation of Kocis. Flora was interviewed by police and provided information relative to Kocis' murder, Blum said in his motion. Because Flora is a potential witness in the case, the public defender's office should be removed, Blum argued." [Note: Al Flora defended Kocis in 2001, when Kocis was charged with sexually assaulting a teenager.]

---

The Times Leader picks up the story:

"A Luzerne County judge on Friday appointed attorneys from outside the public defender’s office to defend Joseph Kerekes on homicide charges in connection with the slaying of Bryan Kocis.

The move came after attorney Jonathan Blum, a public defender, asked for attorneys outside his office to represent the men because of potential conflicts of interest with his office defending both men.

According to Blum’s court papers filed Friday, having public defenders represent both men creates a significant conflict of interest because the men, at trial, could accuse the other as the principal killer.

Also, Blum wrote, he and Al Flora Jr. had represented Kocis in the past. Flora is the county’s first assistant public defender.

Blum wanted outside attorneys appointed for both men but Court of Common Pleas Judge Mark Ciavarella opted to appoint outside attorneys for only Kerekes."

Friday, October 12, 2007

Motions Filed Thus Far...

Several motions and petitions have been filed since October 11, 2007. Both in regards to Harlow Cuadra and Joseph Kerekes. Here's a breakdown thus far:

Harlow Cuadra:

(10/11/2007) Motion for order to Transcribe Record & Order filed by Judge Peter Paul Olszewski.

(10/12/2007) Motion for Appt Conflict Counsel & Order filed by Judge Mark A. Ciavarella, Jr. - this motion has been DENIED.

(10/12/2007) Petition for Appt of Counsel & Order filed by Judge Mark A. Ciavarella, Jr. - this petition has been DENIED.

Joseph Kerekes:

(10/11/2007) Motion for order to Transcribe Record & Order filed by Judge Peter Paul Olszewski.

(10/12/2007) Petition for Appt of Counsel & Order filed - appt Atty Pike-Atty Mark Bufalino-Atty Centini by Judge Mark A. Ciavarella, Jr. - this petition has been Approved.

(10/12/2007) Petition for Appt of Counsel & Order filed by Judge Mark A. Ciavarella, Jr. - this petition has been DENIED.

---
We'll explain these filings in more detail shortly... but needless to say, Joseph Kerekes has been given conflict counsel.

- PC