Showing posts with label Jury Selection. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jury Selection. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

Cuadra's Trial Starts this Morning...

Update 7:00 AM: The Citizens' Voice says: Slumped into the wooden bench 15 feet behind her son, Harlow Cuadra’s mother cupped her face in her hands and wept as the woman explained why she couldn’t be the 12th juror in the capital homicide trial.

“I just can’t believe he did it,” the 99th potential juror said Monday morning before Judge Peter Paul Olzsewski Jr. “He looks like a kid.”

Luzerne County prosecutors will begin their case today, trying to prove that despite his small stature and appearance, 27-year-old Cuadra killed Bryan Charles Kocis at his Dallas Township home in 2007, stabbing Kocis 28 times in the torso before setting fire to his Midland Drive home.

Opening statements will begin at 8:30 a.m. in the trial expected to last about three weeks.

It took five days to reach a jury panel of eight women and four men, as well as four alternate jurors, three men and one woman. Prosecution and defense attorneys interviewed 122 potential jurors individually.

Assistant District Attorney Michael Melnick will give the prosecution’s opening statement. He will outline the commonwealth’s case that Cuadra plotted to kill Kocis, 44, a rival pornography producer in order to lure an actor to his own pornography business. Cuadra operated the business with his partner Joseph Kerekes, 35 in Virginia Beach, Va. Kerekes, who pleaded guilty in December to second-degree homicide and is serving a life sentence, will not testify during the trial.

Melnick and his fellow prosecutors, with more than 100 witnesses, will present a meticulously detailed case they hope will point to Cuadra as Kocis’ killer. Witnesses are expected to testify on everything from forensic evidence at the crime scene, to the location of Cuadra the night Kocis was killed, as well as a supposed admission by Cuadra during a wire-tapped conversation at a nude beach in the La Jolla section of San Diego.

Cuadra, who could face the death penalty if found guilty of first-degree homicide, has remained quiet during the five days of jury selection, speaking rarely and almost exclusively to his attorneys. Occasionally Cuadra has turned from his chair at the defendant’s table to smile at his mother and sister who have watched most of the jury selection.

Kocis’ parents and sister, who have attended almost every hearing related to the case, sat in the front row of the courtroom as jury selection slowly moved through almost 25 hours of questioning.

Cuadra is represented by attorneys Joseph D’Andrea of Dunmore and Paul J. Walker of Scranton. Walker questioned potential jurors, focusing on any bias the jurors might have, particularly related to the death penalty or prejudice against homosexuals. D’Andrea will give the defense’s opening statement. None of the attorneys can comment to the media, because of an order by Olszewski, but the defense is expected to argue Cuadra couldn’t have committed the crime and point to Kerekes as the potential killer.

Update 2:14 AM: According to the Times Leader, prosecutors were moving computers, a projector screen and boxes of evidence into a Luzerne County courtroom Monday night in anticipation of Harlow Cuadra’s capital murder trial.

Opening arguments are set to begin this morning after five sluggish days of selecting 12 jurors and four alternates ended early Monday evening.

Cuadra, 27, could face the death penalty if he is convicted of first-degree homicide in the killing of rival gay pornographic movie producer Bryan Kocis.

Investigators alleged Cuadra and his partner, Joseph Kerekes, 35, both from Virginia Beach, Va., killed Kocis, 44, in his Dallas Township home that they set on fire on Jan. 24, 2007.

Kerekes pleaded guilty on Dec. 8 to second-degree murder and was sentenced to life in prison without parole. Kerekes pledged when he was sentenced that he won’t testify against Cuadra. He is jailed at the State Correctional Institution at Camp Hill.

Assistant district attorneys Michael Melnick, Shannon Crake and Allyson Kacmarski have issued more than 150 subpoenas for witnesses to testify during the expected two- to three-week trial. Most of the witnesses are from other states, including a witness – Robert Wagner – from London, England.

Wagner was allegedly on the telephone speaking with Kocis prior to Kocis’ murder.

Prosecutors are expected to show the jury a number of crime scene and autopsy photographs, surveillance video of Cuadra and Kerekes buying a knife from a pawn shop, and play two recordings of conversations the two men had with Grant Roy and Sean Lockhart in San Diego, in April 2007.

Investigators allege Cuadra and Kerekes made several admissions during the conversations about the homicide and the way Kocis was killed, according to arrest records.

A recording device was placed on Roy when the four men met at a San Diego restaurant on April 27, 2007, and investigators installed a device in an electronic key chain when the four men visited a nude beach on April 28, 2007.

Roy and Lockhart are expected to testify. They were embattled in a federal civil lawsuit against Kocis’ company, Cobra Video, which was settled in January 2007.

Prosecutors allege Cuadra and Kerekes considered Kocis their rival in the gay porn industry, and wanted to film movies with Lockhart, who was under contract by Cobra Video.

The jury is expected to be shown e-mails Cuadra, under the name Danny Moilin, allegedly sent to Kocis.

Investigators allege Cuadra sent Kocis an application to become a model for Cobra Video, and agreed to meet on Jan. 24, 2007.

Cuadra is represented by attorneys Joseph D’Andrea and Paul Walker, who began defending him in December.
---

The Times Leader reports that opening arguments are set to begin Tuesday morning in the Luzerne County capital murder trial against Harlow Cuadra, 27, charged in the killing of rival gay pornographic movie producer Bryan Kocis.

Prosecutors and Cuadra's attorneys chose 12 jurors, and four alternates, in five days of selecting the jury that began last Tuesday.

The jury is made up of eight males and four females. The alternate jurors are made up of three males and one female. In the event a juror is excused for cause, an alternate juror will take their place.

Investigators alleged Cuadra and his partner, Joseph Kerekes, 35, both from Virginia Beach, Va., killed Kocis, 44, inside Kocis' home in Dallas Township on Jan. 24, 2007.

Kerekes pleaded guilty in December to second degree murder, and was sentenced to life in prison without parole.

Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. has scheduled opening arguments to begin at 8:30 a.m. Tuesday.
---

The Citizens' Voice is also reporting that all four alternates and 12 jurors in the capital murder case of Harlow Cuadra have been selected, and opening arguments will begin Tuesday morning.

Prosecutors and defense attorneys interviewed 122 potential jurors to get the panel of eight men and four women. The four alternates are composed of three women and one man.

The panel will decide Cuadra's guilt or innocence in the January 2007 killing of Bryan Kocis, who was stabbed at his Dallas Township home before it was set on fire.

Jury selection started last Tuesday. The high publicity of the case, the possibility of the death penalty and potential bias against Cuadra, who worked in the gay pornography business, have all led to the slow pace of selecting a jury.
---

PC reports: I just got back from my flight/trip (11:48 PM Monday), and will be reporting as normal from today forward... my apologies for the slow reports over the past couple of days, but I did the best I could - remember, it was a vacation. :)

Monday, February 23, 2009

Jury Selection in Cuadra Case Resumes Today

The Citizens' Voice is reporting that Nearly 100 potential jurors for the capital homicide case of Harlow Cuadra have walked through the doors of county Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr.’s courtroom. After four days of questioning, only 11 jurors have made the cut.

Prosecution and defense attorneys will continue their search at 8:30 a.m. today for the 12th juror and four alternates who will decide Cuadra’s guilt or innocence in the January 2007 killing of Bryan Kocis, who was stabbed at his Dallas Township home before it was set on fire.

Jury selection in the case, which started Tuesday, has progressed slowly at times. Prosecution and defense attorneys have interviewed 94 potential jurors individually, for a trial expected to last about three weeks. The high publicity of the case, the fact prosecutors are pursuing the death penalty and any potential bias against Cuadra, who worked in the gay pornography business, have all led to the pace of selecting a jury.

Forty-one potential jurors were dismissed for cause or potential bias, most of them stating they couldn’t impose the death penalty or that they had heard too much about the case. Because prosecutors are pursuing the death penalty, every juror must be willing to consider capital punishment if the jury finds Cuadra guilty of first-degree homicide.

Each side has searched for any potential bias, particularly related to views on homosexuality. Prosecutors allege Cuadra, 27, killed Kocis, a rival producer of gay pornography, in order to eliminate him as a competitor.

Defense Attorney Demetrius Fannick, who is not involved in this case, said jury selection would be expected to take this long, as attorneys are juggling legal issues as well as other factors.

“You’re asking the jury to believe you, to believe your argument,” Fannick said. “That (jury selection) is really the only time you have to interact with the juror to make them feel comfortable, to get them to like you. If you’re on your 30th juror of that day, you might be tired, but you can’t think of that person as one of the countless ones who won’t make the panel, you have to treat that person like the next juror.”

Defense attorneys have struck 18 potential jurors; prosecutors have struck 14. Each side is given 20 challenges while selecting the 12 jurors and two challenges when selecting the four alternates.

Fannick defended Hugo Selenski in his 2006 death penalty trial — he was found not guilty of homicide, but guilty of other charges — when 114 potential jurors were questioned over six days. Fannick said he has had cases where more than 125 potential jurors were interviewed.

District Attorney Jackie Musto Carroll wouldn’t specifically comment about selecting jurors because the Cuadra case is still ongoing but said that in any trial expected to last this long, attorneys will make sure all jurors appear ready to handle the rigors of paying attention to testimony over several weeks.

Fannick said attorneys will have different approaches to jury selection, but the process is as important as the trial itself.

“You go in with a preconceived idea of what you’d like the panel to look like,” he said. “Maybe you want more men or women or blue collar workers. Whatever it is in your mind, you’re trying to get that panel to hear your case.”

So far, Cuadra’s jury is made up of seven men and four women. If the jury and alternates are selected before early afternoon Monday, Olszewski said opening arguments will begin later in the day.

Saturday, February 21, 2009

Cuadra Jury at 11... Selection Continues Monday

The Times Leader is reporting that it looked promising for a man listed as juror 94, a retired railroad employee. He pledged to keep an open mind during Harlow Cuadra’s trial, and understood the penalty phase in a capital murder proceeding.

Lawyers were receptive to his answers until he complained no one on Pennsylvania’s death row is executed.

His opinion got him excused by Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. from serving on the jury that will decide Cuadra’s fate.

Assistant district attorneys Michael Melnick, Shannon Crake and Allyson Kacmarski are seeking the death penalty for Cuadra, 27, charged in the alleged premeditated killing of rival gay pornography movie producer Bryan Kocis in January 2007.

Kocis, 44, was found with a slashed throat, and nearly 30 stab wounds, inside his burned out home on Midland Drive, Dallas Township.

A co-defendant in the case, Joseph Kerekes, 35, pleaded guilty in December to second degree murder and was sentenced to life in prison.

Before he was killed, Kocis told an associate he was meeting a new model on Jan. 24, 2007. Investigators alleged Cuadra set up several e-mail accounts and sent Kocis several e-mails identifying himself as Danny Moilin in a model application for Kocis’ company, Cobra Video.

It was under that disguise, investigators alleged, that Kocis invited Cuadra into his home the night he was killed.

Prosecutors claim the motive to the killing was Cuadra and Kerekes wanted to work with Sean Lockhart, who was a contract model for Cobra Video.

Prosecutors and Cuadra’s attorneys, Joseph D’Andrea and Paul Walker, questioned 94 out of a pool of 125 people specially summoned for the trial during the last four days.

Eleven people – seven males and four females – have been chosen.

The attorneys need to select 12 jurors, plus four alternates, before opening arguments begin.

Olszewski will resume jury selection Monday morning.
---
According to the Citizens' Voice... eleven jurors have been deemed “acceptable” for the capital homicide trial of Harlow Cuadra after a fourth day of jury selection.

Three men were added to the jury Friday from 33 potential jurors interviewed by prosecution and defense attorneys. The jury is now composed of seven men and four women.

Prosecutors are seeking a first-degree homicide conviction of Cuadra, 27, of Virginia Beach, Va., in the killing of Bryan Kocis, 44, of Dallas Township. Kocis was killed in his home in January 2007. Prosecutors allege Cuadra stabbed Kocis, a rival producer of gay pornography, before setting fire to his home, in order to advance his own pornography business.

If Cuadra is found guilty of first-degree homicide, the jury will consider imposing the death penalty or a sentence of life in prison without parole.

The search for the 12th juror and four alternates will resume Monday at 8:30 a.m. at the Luzerne County Courthouse.

Prosecutors and defense attorneys will have to select the five jurors.

Prosecution and defense attorneys probed 94 jurors thus far in a process expected to last at least five days. The defense has struck 18 potential jurors and county prosecutors have struck 14. Each party has been allotted 20 challenges while selecting the 12 jurors. Each side is given two challenges while selecting the alternate four jurors.

Luzerne County Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. said if the five jurors could be chosen by noon on Monday, opening arguments would begin that afternoon. Otherwise, Olszewski said the trial would commence Tuesday morning.

Friday, February 20, 2009

More Jurors Selected in Cuadra Trial

5:16 PM: According to the Times Leader... eleven jurors have been selected for the Luzerne County capital murder trial of Harlow Cuadra, accused in killing a rival gay pornography movie producer.

Three males were accepted by assistant district attorneys Michael Melnick, Shannon Crake and Allyson Kacmarski, and Cuadra's lawyers, Joseph D'Andrea and Paul Walker Friday morning, the fourth day of jury selection.

Investigators alleged Cuadra and his partner, Joseph Kerekes, 35, both from Virginia Beach, Va., killed Bryan Kocis, 44, inside Kocis' home that they set on fire in January 2007.

Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty for Cuadra. Kerekes pleaded guilty in December to second degree murder and was sentenced to life in prison.

Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. will resume jury selection Monday morning.

Currently, the jury is made up with seven males and four females.

11:12 AM: The Citizens' Voice reports that two men were picked as jury members this morning in the capital homicide case of Harlow Cuadra. This brings the jury to 10, six men and four women, with two more jurors and four alternates still needed.

Cuadra, 27, is accused of killing Bryan Kocis at his Dallas Township home, before setting fire to the Midland Drive house. Prosecutors allege Cuadra killed Kocis, 44, a rival producer of gay pornography, in order to lure an actor to the gay pornography business he co-owned with Joseph Kerekes.

Kerekes, 35, pleaded guilty to second-degree homicide in the case.

Jury selection started Tuesday. Prosecutors and defense attorneys have individually interviewed 77 potential jurors thus far. The selection process is set to resume this afternoon. If six more people are not chosen by this afternoon, county Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. said jury selection will continue Monday.

Cuadra Jury Grows to Eight

The Citizens' Voice is reporting that eight jurors have been chosen in the capital homicide trial of Harlow Cuadra, after three days of jury selection.

The 27-year-old Virginia Beach, Va., man could face the death penalty if convicted of first-degree homicide in the killing of Bryan Kocis at his Dallas Township home in January 2007.

The eight jurors — four males and four females — have been selected from 71 possible jurors, who were individually interviewed by prosecution and defense attorneys.

Cuadra is accused of killing Kocis, 44, a rival producer of gay pornography, to lure an actor to the burgeoning pornography enterprise in Virginia Beach he co-owned with Joseph Kerekes. Kerekes, 35, pleaded guilty in December to second-degree homicide in the case.

Kocis’ parents and sister observed from the front row of the courtroom, as jury selection proceeded into the early evening. Thursday, prosecutors and defense attorneys questioned 36 potential jurors’ views regarding the death penalty and their possible prejudices of homosexuals.

Attorneys may move to dismiss up to 15 jurors at any time. By the end of the jury selection session Thursday, the defense had dismissed 13 potential jurors and the prosecution had dismissed 10.

Luzerne County Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. said Thursday given the pace of jury selection thus far, it will likely continue until Monday, when the trial was originally slated to begin.

Opening arguments in the trial are expected to begin Tuesday.
---

[PC Notes: Now that I'm up here [Alaska], and got a good night's sleep, I'll be checking in from time to time to ensure updates, and comments are once again current.]

Thursday, February 19, 2009

Selection of Cuadra Jury Goes Slowly

Harlow Cuadra

The Times Leader reports this morning that a man listed as juror 16 didn’t stay long inside a Luzerne County courtroom on Wednesday. He walked to the witness stand, raised his right hand and promised to tell the truth.

His answer to the first question from Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. was enough to have him excused from serving on the jury panel in the capital murder case of Harlow Cuadra.

“I’m prejudiced against (Cuadra) lifestyle, gay pornography; I can’t deal with that,” the man said.

Prosecutors alleged Cuadra, 27, and his partner, Joseph Kerekes, 35, both from Virginia Beach, Va., killed rival gay pornography movie producer Bryan Kocis at Kocis’ Dallas Township home in January 2007.

Kerekes pleaded guilty in December to second-degree murder and was sentenced to life in prison without parole. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty for Cuadra.

So far, 35 members of the pool of 125 have been questioned in two days. Five have been accepted to serve on the jury.

On Wednesday, 24 were questioned, with 12 excused by the judge for legal cause, five dismissed by prosecutors and five excused by Cuadra’s lawyers.

Juror No. 16 was excused by Olszewski. The excused juror was the only juror questioned in two days to express his bias against gay pornography. Most jurors who have been excused said they couldn’t impose the death penalty.

Assistant district attorneys Michael Melnick, Shannon Crake and Allyson Kacmarski, and Cuadra’s lawyers, Joseph D’Andrea and Paul Walker, are hoping to select a jury of 12 plus four alternates by Friday afternoon.

The slow pace of selecting the jury caused Olszewski to advise attorneys that the trial may start Tuesday, altering his plan to have opening arguments begin on Monday.

Two women and three men have been chosen for the jury. Both women said they suffer from diabetes, including one who takes medication for depression. One is a homemaker and the other woman is a hostess at a restaurant.

Two of the men are retired and the third man is a laborer at InterMetro Industries in Wilkes-Barre.

Jury selection is scheduled to resume this morning.
---

Meanwhile, the Citizens' Voice reports that four more jurors were selected Wednesday in the capital homicide trial of Harlow Cuadra of Virginia Beach, Va., who is accused of killing Bryan Kocis and setting fire to his Back Mountain home in January 2007. Nearly one-third of the jurors needed have been picked in the high profile trial.

A total of five jurors — three men and two women — have been selected out of 35 potential jurors individually interviewed by prosecution and defense attorneys since Tuesday. Twelve jurors and four alternates will be chosen before the start of the trial, which county Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. said he hopes will begin Monday.

Selection has been slow as attorneys have scrutinized potential jurors, particularly questioning them about their beliefs on the death penalty and any prejudices against homosexuals.

Cuadra, 27, and Kocis, 44, worked in the gay pornography business. Prosecutors allege Cuadra slashed Kocis’ neck and stabbed his torso nearly 30 times at his Midland Drive home in Dallas Township in order to lure an actor who worked for Kocis to the fledgling pornography business Cuadra co-owned with Joseph Kerekes, also of Virginia Beach.

Prosecutors were pursuing the death penalty against Kerekes, 35, as well, before he pleaded guilty to second-degree homicide in December. Kerekes is serving a life sentence and has said he will not testify against Cuadra.

Prosecutors have dismissed eight potential jurors and defense attorneys have dismissed seven. Each side can move to dismiss 30 potential jurors for any reason, leaving the prosecution with 22 strikes and the defense with 23, as jury selection resumes today at 8:30 a.m.
---

[PC Notes: I'll be heading out to the airport shortly, and will be on a plane or at an airport until 7-7:30 p.m. eastern time (Anchorage is 4 hours behind). I'll try to do some updates while I'm at the airport[s] waiting for my connection[s], and will certainly have a full report later today.

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Cuadra Jury Selection Continues

6:05 PM: The Citizens' Voice chimes in: A fifth juror was selected Wednesday afternoon in the capital homicide case of Harlow Cuadra, who is accused of killing Bryan Kocis and setting fire to his Back Mountain home in January 2007.

Three men and two women have been selected for the jury panel so far. Jury selection concluded for the day and will resume Thursday at 8:30 a.m. Jury selection began Tuesday. A total of 12 jurors and four alternates must be selected for the trial.

Prosecution and defense attorneys can move to dismiss 30 potential jurors each for any reason. Prosecutors have dismissed eight and defense attorneys dismissed seven potential jurors. The additional 15 potential jurors not selected for the panel were removed for potential conflicts or medical reasons.

4:58 PM: Once again the Times Leader reports that five jurors have been chosen in the Luzerne County capital murder trial of Harlow Cuadra.

A male retired employee at the Tobyhanna Army Depot, a male retired postal worker, a female hostess at a restaurant, and a male employed at Inter Metro were accepted by assistant district attorneys and Cuadra's lawyers today.

The total number of jurors selected through 31 people individually questioned is five. A female homemaker was chosen on Tuesday.

4:42 PM: The Times Leader is reporting that four jurors have been chosen in the Luzerne County capital murder trial of Harlow Cuadra.

A male retired employee at the Tobyhanna Army Depot, a male retired postal worker and a female hostess at a restaurant were accepted by assistant district attorneys and Cuadra's lawyers today.

The total number of jurors selected through 31 people individually questioned is four.

1:40 PM: The Citizens' Voice reports that Two more jurors were selected this morning in the capital homicide case of Harlow Cuadra, who is accused of killing Bryan Kocis and setting fire to his Back Mountain home in January 2007.

Jury selection began Tuesday. A total of 24 potential jurors were individually interviewed, with a total of three selected so far.

Prosecution and defense attorneys can move to dismiss 30 potential jurors each for any reason. Prosecutors dismissed seven jurors and defense attorneys dismissed four jurors so far. The additional 10 potential jurors not selected for the panel were removed by county Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. for potential conflicts.

Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty against Cuadra, 27, who is accused of slashing Kocis' neck and stabbing his torso nearly 30 times.

Cuadra, along with his former lover and business partner Joseph Kerekes, 35, are accused of killing Kocis, 44, a rival gay pornography producer, to lure an actor to their fledgling pornography business. Kerekes pleaded guilty in December to second-degree homicide in the case and is serving a life sentence.

11:40 AM: Sources tell me that out of the 19 interviewed they have 2. One guy and one girl with 25 more people coming in after 1:00 PM.

11:35 AM: The Times Leader is reporting that a second juror has been chosen in the Luzerne County capital murder trial of Harlow Cuadra.

A male, a retired employee at the Tobyhanna Army Depot, was accepted by assistant district attorneys and Cuadra's lawyers earlier today.

Attorneys are hoping to empanel a jury of 12 plus four alternates by Friday afternoon. Testimony is set to begin Monday before Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr.

Prosecutors alleged Cuadra, 27, and his partner, Joseph Kerekes, 35, both from Virginia Beach, Va., killed rival gay pornographic movie producer Bryan Kocis, 44, at Kocis' Dallas Township home on Jan. 24, 2007.

Kerekes pleaded guilty in December to second degree murder and was sentenced to life in prison without parole.

Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty for Cuadra.

Attorneys are individually questioning each potential juror. Ten people were questioned Tuesday with a female - a homemaker -accepted to the jury.

During Wednesday's selection process, a man was excused because he said, "I don't believe in taking life at all," and another male was excused for cause after he claimed, "I'm against (Cuadra's) lifestyle, gay pornography; I can't deal with that."

A man questioned this morning was excused because he said he already found Cuadra guilty from published and broadcast reports.

Cuadra, dressed in a tan jacket and tie, is taking notes during the selection process, and often conversing with his lawyers - Joseph D'Andrea and Paul Walker. His mother and sister are in the courtroom, in addition to Kocis' parents and sister.

One Juror Selected in Cuadra Murder Trial

The Citizens' Voice reports that Harlow Cuadra wore a gray suit and purple shirt Tuesday to meet the people who could decide his fate.

“Good morning,” said Cuadra, standing at the defense table and waving to 125 potential jurors before jury selection began in his capital homicide case.

Cuadra, 27, of Virginia Beach, Va., is accused of killing Bryan Kocis and setting fire to his Dallas Township home in January 2007. Along with his former business partner Joseph Kerekes, who already pleaded guilty to second-degree homicide, Cuadra is accused of eliminating Kocis, a rival producer, in an attempt to lure an actor to their fledgling gay pornography business in Virginia Beach.

Prosecutors and defense attorneys interviewed 10 prospective jurors Tuesday afternoon, selecting only one — an older woman. Prosecutors dismissed three potential witnesses and Cuadra’s attorneys dismissed two; each side is allowed to dismiss 30 potential jurors from the pool. The other four potential jurors removed from the pool Tuesday were dismissed for medical reasons or potential conflicts.

Twelve jurors and four alternates will be selected in the next several days, Judge Peter Paul Olzsewski Jr. said. He told prospective jurors the trial, which he hopes will begin Monday, could last three weeks.

Each juror was questioned on familiarity with the high-profile case and his or her ability to ignore any previous knowledge obtained through media accounts. Jurors were also questioned on their opinions of the death penalty, as prosecutors are pursuing it against Cuadra.

Cuadra is accused of slashing Kocis’ neck, nearly decapitating him and stabbing his torso nearly 30 times. Kerekes, 35, who also faced the death penalty, pleaded guilty in December to second-degree homicide in the case and is serving a life sentence.

Unrelated to jury selection, Olszewski ruled Tuesday afternoon that evidence seized from Cuadra’s BMW M5 sedan at the time of his May 2007 arrest, including a knife and laptop computer, can be used in the case.

Attorneys for Cuadra and Kerekes, before he pleaded guilty, had argued the evidence shouldn’t be used because it was seized by Virginia Beach police as part of a separate investigation. Virginia Beach police were investigating a prostitution ring, believed to be run by Cuadra and Kerekes. Olszewski dismissed Cuadra’s motion to suppress the evidence, writing that the evidence was gathered following “standard police procedures.”

Meanwhile, WBRE is saying prosecutors and defense attorneys Tuesday apparently could agree on just one candidate for their jury to hear the case of Bryan Kocis and the man accused of killing him. A total of 10 people were questioned. A full jury might not be seated until the end of the week.

Harlow Cuadra is charged with homicide. He asked for prayers while leaving the courthouse late Tuesday afternoon. Cuadra denies prosecutors' claims that he murdered the gay porn producer. Alleged partner Joseph Kerekes pleaded guilty to homicide in December and is behind bars for life. Cuadra could get the death penalty if convicted.

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Jury Selection Begins in Cuadra Trial

4:30 PM: A court watcher tells me that Kocis' family was present today, unsure if any of Harlow or Joe's family was there... will try to have an answer to that tomorrow.

4:16 PM: The Times Leader reports that one person has been selected to the jury panel for the Luzerne County capital murder case of Harlow Cuadra.

Ten prospective jurors were questioned by Court of Common Pleas Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr., assistant district attorneys and defense lawyers Tuesday afternoon.

A woman in her 60s, who is also a diabetic, was chosen. She was the first juror questioned individually.

Prosecutors dismissed three people, and Cuadra's lawyers dismissed two.

Each side was given 20 excuses to dismiss prospective jurors.

Jury selection is scheduled to resume Wednesday morning.

3:04 PM: Defense's motion to suppress the evidence seized from the BMW in Virginia Beach, VA has been denied.

1:10 PM: According to the Citizens' Voice... jury selection began Tuesday morning in the capital homicide case of Harlow Cuadra.

Cuadra, 27, of Virginia Beach, Va., is accused of killing Bryan Kocis in his Dallas Township home in January 2007. Prosecutors say Cuarda and his business partner, Joseph Kerekes, plotted to kill Kocis, a rival producer of gay pornography.

Luzerne County Judge Peter Paul Olszewski asked general questions of 125 possible jurors this morning. All but approximately 20 potential jurors said they had heard about the case.

Twenty of the possible jurors will be individually questioned this afternoon by defense and prosecution attorneys. Twelve jurors and four alternates must be selected. No one has been selected so far.

Cuadra, who faces an open count of homicide, as well as arson and other charges, could face the death penalty if convicted. Cuadra's co-defendant, Kerekes, 44, pleaded guilty Dec. 8 to second-degree murder and other charges and was sentenced to life in prison without parole, the mandatory term for a second-degree murder conviction.

12:52 PM: I'm hearing that they just finished the group address... kept 25 people and sent the rest home for the day. Somewhat surprising (or maybe not)... is that a large group of people indicated that they know absolutely nothing about the case.

12:16 PM: Sources tell me that as of 12:05 PM, individual voir dire has not begun.

10:18 AM: Sources tell me that it'll start with all of the prospective jurors coming in and filling out a giant questionaire... the panel will be talked to as a whole or in groups... and then everyone will review the questions and individually call up every single person and ask the same questions over and over. I'm told not to expect any more than 1 or 2 jurors to be seated today.

9:51 AM: The Times Leader is reporting that jury selection is set to begin today in the Luzerne County capital murder trial of Harlow Cuadra, charged in the killing of Bryan Kocis, 44, more than two years ago in Dallas Township.

Prosecutors alleged Cuadra, 27, and his partner, Joseph Kerekes, 35, killed Kocis, whom they considered their rival in the gay pornographic movie industry. Kocis was found dead inside his burned out home on Jan. 24, 2007. Kerekes pleaded guilty to second degree murder in December, and was sentenced to life in prison without parole.

Two hundred people received notices to report for jury duty at the courthouse this week. Out of that number, 125 prospective jurors will be questioned for the Cuadra trial. The other 75 prospective jurors will be assigned to other trials scheduled this week.

Cuadra's trial before Court of Common Pleas Judge Peter Paul Olszewski Jr. is expected to take two to three weeks.

Monday, February 16, 2009

What to Expect this Week: Jury Selection 101 (Redux)

Harlow Cuadra's trial for the brutal slaying of Bryan Kocis begins tomorrow (02/17/09)... the first step is jury selection... which is expected to take 4-5 days. While regular readers of this blog have probably already seen these posts before... I'd like to offer an easy way to view them for those that haven't:

1. Jury Selection
2. Harlow's Proposed Voir Dire (Jury Questionnaire)
3. What Happens once the Jury has been Selected

What else to expect: This entire jury selection procedure will likely be very boring. From what I've been told: "experienced media dread covering jury selections, even in the high-profile cases. They literally ask the same questions over and over and over to every single potential juror for 7 or 8 hours a day."

Sounds like fun... NOT... hence me planning to go on 02/26.

Wednesday, January 7, 2009

Harlow Cuadra's Trial... Step 1

Harlow Cuadra

With Harlow Cuadra's trial scheduled to begin on February 17, 2009, for the brutal slaying of Bryan Kocis, I thought I'd go ahead and post a guide as to what happens first: jury selection... and how that process is done. Since this is a capital case, Harlow's jury selection alone could easily take a week or more:

1. Jury Procedures
2. Examination and Challenges of the Trial Jurors
3. Juror Information Questionnaire
4. Examination and Challenges of Alternate Trial Jurors
5. Number of Peremptory Challenges
6. Exhaustion of the Jury Panel

Source: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Code

Jury Procedures

Rule 630. Juror Qualification Form, Lists of Trial Jurors, and Challgene to the Array.

(A) JUROR QUALIFICATION FORM AND LISTS OF TRIAL JURORS.

(1) The officials designated by law to select persons for jury service shall:

(a) devise, distribute, and maintain juror qualification forms as provided by law;

(b) prepare, publish, and post lists of the names of persons to serve as jurors as provided by law; and

(c) upon the request of the attorney for the Commonwealth or the defendant’s attorney, furnish the list containing the names of prospective jurors prepared pursuant to paragraph (A)(1)(b); and

(d) make available for review and copying copies of the juror qualification forms returned by the prospective jurors.

(2) The information provided on the juror qualification form shall be confidential and limited to questions of the jurors’ qualifications.

(3) The original and any copies of the juror qualification form shall not constitute a public record.

(B) CHALLENGE TO THE ARRAY.

(1) Unless opportunity did not exist prior thereto, a challenge to the array shall be made not later than 5 days before the first day of the week the case is listed for trial of criminal cases for which the jurors have been summoned and not thereafter, and shall be in writing, specifying the facts constituting the ground for the challenge.

(2) A challenge to the array may be made only on the ground that the jurors were not selected, drawn, or summoned substantially in accordance with law.

Examination and Challenges of the Trial Jurors

Rule 631. Examination and Challenges of the Trial Jurors.

(A) Voir dire of prospective trial jurors and prospective alternate jurors shall be conducted, and the jurors shall be selected, in the presence of a judge, unless the judge’s presence is waived by the attorney for the Commonwealth, the defense attorney, and the defendant, with the judge’s consent.

(B) This oath shall be administered individually or collectively to the prospective jurors:

‘‘You do solemnly swear by Almighty God (or do declare and affirm) that you will answer truthfully all questions that may be put to you concerning your qualifications for service as a juror.’’

(C) Voir dire, including the judge’s ruling on all proposed questions, shall be recorded in full unless the recording is waived. The record will be transcribed only upon written request of either party or order of the judge.

(D) Prior to voir dire, each prospective juror shall complete the standard, confidential juror information questionnaire as provided in Rule 632. The judge may require the parties to submit in writing a list of proposed questions to be asked of the jurors regarding their qualifications. The judge may permit the defense and the prosecution to conduct the examination of prospective jurors or the judge may conduct the examination. In the latter event, the judge shall permit the defense and the prosecution to supplement the examination by such further inquiry as the judge deems proper.

(E) In capital cases, the individual voir dire method must be used, unless the defendant waives that alternative. In non-capital cases, the trial judge shall select one of the following alternative methods of voir dire, which shall apply to the selection of both jurors and alternates:

(1) INDIVIDUAL VOIR DIRE AND CHALLENGE SYSTEM.

(a) Voir dire of prospective jurors shall be conducted individually and may be conducted beyond the hearing and presence of other jurors.

(b) Challenges, both peremptory and for cause, shall be exercised alternately, beginning with the attorney for the Commonwealth, until all jurors are chosen. Challenges shall be exercised immediately after the prospective juror is examined. Once accepted by all parties, a prospective juror shall not be removed by peremptory challenge. Without declaring a mistrial, a judge may allow a challenge for cause at any time before the jury begins to deliberate, provided sufficient alternates have been selected, or the defendant consents to be tried by a jury of fewer than 12, pursuant to Rule 641.

(2) LIST SYSTEM OF CHALLENGES.

(a) A list of prospective jurors shall be prepared. The list shall contain a sufficient number of prospective jurors to total at least 12, plus the number of alternates to be selected, plus the total number of peremptory challenges (including alternates).

(b) Prospective jurors may be examined collectively or individually regarding their qualifications. If the jurors are examined individually, the examination may be conducted beyond the hearing and presence of other jurors.

(c) Challenges for cause shall be exercised orally as soon as the cause is determined.

(d) When a challenge for cause has been sustained, which brings the total number on the list below the number of 12 plus alternates, plus peremptory challenges (including alternates), additional prospective jurors shall be added to the list.

(e) Each prospective juror subsequently added to the list may be examined as set forth in paragraph (E)(2)(b).

(f) When the examination has been completed and all challenges for cause have been exercised, peremptory challenges shall then be exercised by passing the list between prosecution and defense, with the prosecution first striking the name of a prospective juror, followed by the defense, and alternating thereafter until all peremptory challenges have been exhausted. If either party fails to exhaust all peremptory challenges, the jurors last listed shall be stricken. The remaining jurors and alternates shall be seated. No one shall disclose which party peremptorily struck any juror.

Juror Information Questionnaire

Rule 632. Juror Information Questionnaire.

(A) Prior to voir dire:

(1) Each prospective juror shall complete and verify the standard, confidential juror information questionnaire required by paragraph (H) of this rule, and any supplemental questionnaire provided by the court.

(2) The president judge shall designate the method for distributing and maintaining the juror information questionnaires.

(3) The trial judge and the attorneys shall receive copies of the completed questionnaires for use during voir dire, and the attorneys shall be given a reasonable opportunity to examine the questionnaires.

(B) The information provided by the jurors on the questionnaires shall be confidential and limited to use for the purpose of jury selection only. Except for disclosures made during voir dire, or unless the trial judge otherwise orders pursuant to paragraph (F), this information shall only be made available to the trial judge, the defendant(s) and the attorney(s) for the defendant(s), and the attorney for the Commonwealth.

(C) The original and any copies of the juror information questionnaires shall not constitute a public record.

(D) Juror information questionnaires shall be used in conjunction with the examination of the prospective jurors conducted by the judge or counsel pursuant to Rule 631(D).

(E) If the court adjourns before voir dire is completed, the trial judge may order that the attorneys be permitted to retain their copies of the questionnaires during the adjournment. When copies of the questionnaires are permitted to be taken from the courtroom, the copies:

(1) shall continue to be subject to the confidentiality requirements of this rule, and to the disclosure requirements of paragraph (B); and

(2) shall not be duplicated, distributed, or published.

The trial judge may make such other order to protect the copies as is appropriate.

(F) The original questionnaires of all impaneled jurors shall be retained in a sealed file and shall be destroyed upon completion of the jurors’ service, unless otherwise ordered by the trial judge. Upon completion of voir dire, all copies of the questionnaires shall be returned to the trial judge and destroyed, unless otherwise ordered by the trial judge at the request of the defendant(s), the attorney(s) for the defendant(s), or the attorney for the Commonwealth.

(G) The original and any copies of questionnaires of all prospective jurors not impaneled or not selected for any trial shall be destroyed upon completion of the jurors’ service.

(H) The form of the juror information questionnaire shall be as follows:





I hereby certify that the answers on this form are true and correct. I understand that false answers provided herein subject me to penalties under 18 Pa.C.S. § 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.

SIGNATURE

---------
DATE

---------

Examination and Challenges of Alternate Trial Jurors

Rule 633. Examination and Challenges of Alternate Trial Jurors.

(A) The trial judge may direct that a reasonable even number of jurors in addition to the principal jurors be called and impaneled to sit as alternate jurors.

(B) When alternate jurors are selected in trials involving only one defendant, the defendant and the Commonwealth shall each be entitled to one peremptory challenge for each 2 alternate jurors to be selected. When alternate jurors are selected in trials involving joint defendants, each defendant shall be entitled to one peremptory challenge for each two 2 alternate jurors to be selected and the Commonwealth shall be entitled to peremptory challenges equal in number to the total number of peremptory challenges given to all of the defendants. All peremptory challenges remaining unexercised after the selection of the principal 12 jurors shall be considered exhausted, and in no case may the challenges reserved for the selection of alternates be added to the number allowed during the selection of the principal 12.

(C) Alternate jurors shall be examined, challenged, and selected in the same manner as the principal jurors.

Number of Peremptory Challenges

Rule 634. Number of Peremptory Challenges.

(A) Trials Involving Only One Defendant:

(1) In trials involving misdemeanors only and when there is only one defendant, the Commonwealth and the defendant shall each be entitled to 5 peremptory challenges.

(2) In trials involving a non-capital felony and when there is only one defendant, the Commonwealth and the defendant shall each be entitled to 7 peremptory challenges.

(3) In trials involving a capital felony and when there is only one defendant, the Commonwealth and the defendant shall each be entitled to 20 peremptory challenges.

Exhaustion of the Jury Panel

Rule 635. Exhaustion of the Jury Panel.

When a sufficient number of qualified jurors are not present to permit selection of a jury, the court shall:

(1) Require the officials designated by law to summon prospective jurors to summon and return immediately from the county at large as many qualified and competent persons as shall be necessary; or

(2) Order in writing that the officials designated by law to summon prospective jurors produce the jury wheel or master list in open court in the presence of the judge, and draw therefrom five names for each juror required. A venire shall then be issued requiring that those persons so drawn be brought into court at a time certain.